Today we’re mining for some hidden gem restaurants in Saint Augustine. These are dining spots that often fly under the radar. If you’re tired of the usual tourist traps and want to savor some hidden gems, this list has got you covered. From cozy cafes to delightful eateries, these ten spots will offer tasty experiences that are definitely worth seeking out.

Murf’s Homestyle ToGo

Murf’s Homestyle ToGo is a spot you shouldn’t skip when in St. Augustine. Their fried chicken is crispy and juicy, served with creamy mashed potatoes that make you feel right at home. Check out their menu here for more tasty options!

The Drunken Horse

The Drunken Horse is a cozy spot that celebrates good food and great company. Their charcuterie boards are a definite highlight, featuring a mix of meats, cheeses, and fresh bread that’s perfect for sharing. Grab a friend and indulge in a delightful tasting experience that you won’t forget!

To learn more about this fantastic dining option, check out The Drunken Horse.

Drake’s Bistro

Drake’s Bistro is a must-visit spot in St. Augustine. Their sandwiches are made fresh, with layers of tasty meats and crisp veggies that will satisfy any appetite. Check out more about their offerings here!

The Spanish Bakery & Cafe

The Spanish Bakery & Cafe is a must-visit spot for anyone craving authentic flavors. Their freshly baked empanadas and delicious soups will make your taste buds dance with joy. Don’t miss out on trying their special recipes, which you can find more about at The Spanish Bakery & Cafe.

Sarbez!

If you’re in the mood for comfort food, Sarbez! is the place to be. Their gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches are a hit, with gooey cheese and crispy bread that make every bite delightful. Pair it with their tasty fries and you’ve got a meal that feels like a warm hug!

Catch 27

Catch 27 is a seafood lover’s delight in St. Augustine. Their fresh fish dishes are always on point, with local flavors taking center stage. Make sure to try their signature dishes for a taste of what makes this spot a must-visit!

Learn more about their offerings here: Catch 27.

The Floridian Restaurant

The Floridian Restaurant offers a taste of local flavors with its fresh seafood and Southern-inspired dishes. Their shrimp and grits are a must-try, combining creamy textures with perfectly cooked shrimp. For more information, check out The Floridian’s page to see what else tempts your taste buds!

Forgotten Tonic

Forgotten Tonic is a hidden gem that serves up a mouthwatering steak that’s hard to forget. The tender meat paired with creamy sides makes every bite a treat. Don’t miss their unique cocktails that perfectly complement the meal, making it a spot you’ll want to return to!

Mango Mango’s Caribbean Grill

Mango Mango’s Caribbean Grill is a must-visit spot in St. Augustine. Their juicy grilled chicken skewers paired with rice and plantains are simply irresistible. Check out their page and plan your visit for a taste of the Caribbean!

Old City House Inn & Restaurant

Located in the charming streets of St. Augustine, Old City House Inn & Restaurant offers a delightful menu with a focus on fresh, local ingredients. Their creamy risotto topped with perfectly seared scallops is a must-try, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. To learn more about this hidden gem, check out their website here.